getAbstract

Home | Knowledge Packs | Travel Packs |
Blog | RSS Feeds | Free Summaries

Why Great Leaders Don't Take Yes for an Answer

Managing for Conflict and Consensus

by Michael A. Roberto

Wharton School Publishing, 2005

Category: Leadership & Management

Get the summary
Why Great Leaders Don't Take Yes for an Answer

getAbstract rating

Overall (?)

rating 8 (8)

Applicability

rating 9 (9)

Innovation

rating 6 (6)

Style

rating 8 (8)

Level of Expertise (?)

rating 6 (6)

User rating (2 comments)

  (1 rating)

In this summary you will learn

  • Why constructive conflict is so important and how to guide it
  • What most organizations do that shuts down dissent

Why you should read Why Great Leaders Don't Take Yes for an Answer

The two greatest strengths of Michael A. Roberto's book are its honesty and clarity. He admits that most people are uncomfortable with conflict and that many well-intentioned leaders shut down dissent. He's also honest about how likely it is that things will go wrong along the way, at least temporarily. Fortunately, he's also very clear about steps you can take to guide conflict in a productive direction, and why this matters. Roberto analyzes several well-known examples of bad decision making and shows how the absence of dissent or institutional mechanisms that insulated decision makers from essential - though not necessarily positive - information created serious problems. The list is long and chilling: President John F. Kennedy and the Bay of Pigs, President Lyndon B. Johnson and Vietnam, NASA and the Columbia shuttle explosion. His discussions will give you a powerful desire to review your organization's decision-making processes and, more generally, its culture. As Roberto himself readily admits, his techniques are not cure-alls, nor easy, but they will lead to improvements. getAbstract recommends this book to managers with decision-making responsibilities and to anyone who is committed to improving organizational functioning.

About the Author

Michael A. Roberto teaches at Harvard Business School and twice won Harvard's Allyn Young Prize for Teaching in Economics. He has consulted with a range of corporations.

Comment on this summary     Sign in to share your opinion

Celeste Kreyfelt July 14, 2011

I especially enjoyed the section - "provoke productive conflicts" and introducing Mental Simulations for projects or activities to try and anticipate any possible failures.

This also falls in line with the core purpose of Manage a function - ENSURE TOMORROW'S PROBLEMS ARE ADDRESSED TODAY.

Erica Rauzin July 14, 2011

Celeste - That is a terrific summation of a manager's function. Thanks! As a getAbstract editor, I really appreciate seeing so much good sense phrased so succinctly.