Firm Feedback in a Fragile World
A review of

Firm Feedback in a Fragile World

How to Build a Winning Culture with Critical Conversations


A Workplace Starved of Straight Talk

by Deirdre Cody

Few phrases clear a break room faster than “We need to talk.” Executive coach Jeff Hancher argues that the dread is the real problem, not the feedback itself. His practical guide makes a persuasive, often entertaining case that well-delivered criticism doesn’t just fix performance; it unlocks potential.

Executive coach Jeff Hancher highlights a striking paradox: Though some 75% of employees want more feedback from their managers, almost 70% of managers admit they’re uncomfortable giving it. This reluctance isn’t baseless. A 2017 study found that employees tend to withdraw from, or turn aggressive toward, bosses who deliver bad news. The result is a working culture starved of feedback at the very moment that record numbers of employees feel disengaged.

Influential leaders want to see people grow! If you don’t want to help others grow, don’t be a leader.Jeff Hancher

Hancher’s prescription is cheap: Forget expensive perks and benefits; boost engagement by giving employees consistent, meaningful feedback. A Gallup survey corroborates this recommendation, finding that workers who receive weekly feedback are four times more engaged than those who don’t. Just as children thrive when parents set clear boundaries, Hancher argues, employees thrive with constructive guidance.


Comment on this review