Summary of Does Torture Work?

Oxford UP, more...

Buy the book

Does Torture Work? book summary
Some people abide the horrors of torture because they think it can reveal critical information. But does it really work? Not according to game theory.

Rating

8 Overall

8 Importance

10 Innovation

7 Style

Recommendation

Fairleigh Dickinson University professor John W. Schiemann applies game theory to the horrors of torture to show that torture cannot yield valuable information. His analysis proves thought provoking and convincing. Schiemann reviews philosophical, ethical and political arguments for and against torture, and he evaluates how torture functions in practice as an information-gathering technique. Because Schiemann describes dreadful torture techniques and conducts his analysis using symbolic reasoning and quite complex game theory, his approach isn’t for every reader, although he restates most points in simpler prose. While any discussion of torture is sensitive and difficult to bear, including this one, getAbstract recommends these groundbreaking research insights to those interested in the military, politics, the war on terrorism, game theory and ethical decision making.

In this summary, you will learn

  • How proponents justify torture on security and information grounds
  • What a game theory model and evaluation of torture reveals
  • How and why torture never succeeds
 

Summary

Thinking About Torture
In the argument for or against using torture to secure critical wartime information, “pragmatists” support torture if it gleans useful information. People known as “Kantians”– named for philosopher Immanuel Kant – believe that torture is simply wrong. “Khanians” – ...
Get the key points from this book in less than 10 minutes. Learn more about our products or log in

About the Author

Author of The Policy of Pact-Making, John W. Schiemann is an associate professor of political science at Fairleigh Dickinson University.


Comment on this summary

More on this topic

Customers who read this summary also read

More by category